Singularity Digital vs First Page Sage: Which Fits Your Stage?

Singularity Digital and First Page Sage both run SEO and GEO for B2B SaaS companies and have great results to show for it, but each one targets companies at a different stage and shapes its services, processes, and pricing accordingly. First Page Sage is set up for established companies that want to dominate their whole category in search and AI, and have the budget for a bigger program that makes it possible. Singularity works with early-stage SaaS teams that also want to show up in search and AI, but they need to maximize spend and are up against bigger, better-known competitors. 

As Singularity, we’d love to work with you, but we know we aren’t the right fit for every company. So we’ll be clear about which companies each agency suits best, and you can decide which one fits yours.

Singularity Digital vs First Page Sage: At a Glance

Singularity DigitalFirst Page Sage
Stage fitEarly-stage B2B SaaS, $1-10M ARREstablished growth-stage and enterprise companies
PricingFrom $3K/month for SEO and GEO$6K to $12K/month, priced as monthly deliverable credits
People on your accountOur founder, Patrick Herbert, plus an SEO account manager, writer, editor, and outreach specialistA campaign manager as your main contact, plus an SEO strategist, writers, an editor, graphic artists, and web developers
Primary specializationGetting early-stage SaaS in front of the buyers it serves best, even against bigger competitorsMaking established companies the first name buyers and AI reach for in a crowded category

Who is Singularity Digital

We’re Singularity Digital, an SEO and GEO agency founded by Patrick Herbert to help SaaS companies in the $1-10M ARR range grow through search. For the past 12 years, we’ve worked closely with SaaS companies to help them increase recognition and revenue, so we know the challenges they face and what it takes to overcome them. We’re also building our own SaaS product, so we know firsthand what it’s like to market something new against bigger, better-known competitors.

Read these case studies for proof of Singularity Digital’s work:

Who is First Page Sage

First Page Sage is an SEO and GEO agency founded by Evan Bailyn in 2009. Its SaaS client list leans enterprise, with names like Salesforce, Dassault Systèmes, and Cadence. 

On their SaaS SEO page, they clearly say that First Page Sage is a strong fit for companies in crowded categories that want to be the first name buyers and AI reach for, and it isn’t a fit for companies without the budget for a senior-level program. First Page Sage was also one of the first agencies to offer GEO, launching its service in 2023, and it has since added agentic search optimization.

Read these case studies for proof of First Page Sage’s work:

Services: Singularity vs First Page Sage

Singularity Digital’s Core process

We begin with a technical SEO audit of your site and an audit of your brand’s visibility in search and AI. Technical issues get fixed first, and while that’s happening, we look at your product, talk to your team, and study your market to see where you have room to stand out against competitors.

Once we know your strongest selling points, we run keyword and prompt research to find the searches your buyers make around them, including the smaller searches AI runs in the background before it answers. That tells us exactly what your content needs to cover, on your site and off it, with the same brand message about what makes your product stand out. When search engines and AI keep seeing that message, they connect your brand with it and recommend you to the buyers looking for exactly that. It all goes into your 12-month SEO workbook, with a forecast of the results you can expect.

Singularity Digital’s Core Services at a glance:

B2B SaaS SEO + GEO
Keyword research to find what buyers search for on Google, scored by revenue potential, funnel stage, and buyer intent
Prompt and fan-out research to see what buyers ask AI tools and how AI breaks those questions into multiple searches, using our own Query Fan-Out Tool
Content creation and refreshes based on SME insight from your team
Content distribution across LinkedIn, Reddit, Medium, and industry publications
Technical SEO, including crawl fixes, structured schema, and sameAs entity work so LLMs recognize your brand as one entity
Conversion optimization of key product and landing pages, so the traffic you earn turns into sign-ups and demos 
Link building through vetted, relevant sites
Digital PR to earn brand mentions on sources buyers and AI already trust
SaaS PPC 
Campaign management across Google Ads, Bing Ads, display, and remarketing
Landing page optimization of CTAs and pages from your ICP’s perspective
SEO Consulting
Strategy and roadmap for in-house SEO teams that handle their own execution
White Label SEO + GEO
Done-for-you search services for agencies that want to offer SEO and GEO under their own brand

First Page Sage’s Core Process

First Page Sage uses the first month to set your strategy. They audit where you rank in search and AI, how those platforms describe your product, handle your technical fixes, and research keywords across your whole category and buying journey, since the goal is to make you the first name buyers and AI reach for across all of it.

They start putting the strategy into action in month two, with thought leadership content as their main lever. Their in-house writers build each piece from regular input from your team, and each month they deliver a set number of pieces depending on your engagement. 

First Page Sage’s core services at a glance:

B2B SaaS SEO + GEO
Keyword research across your whole category and buying journey
GEO/AEO to shape how AI describes and recommends your brand, through list placements, reviews, and AI reputation monitoring
Thought leadership content from in-house writers, including use case pages, comparison articles, and original research
Technical SEO, including site architecture, indexation, and site speed
Digital PR placements on outside sites to build brand authority
Agentic Search Optimization
Getting your site ready for AI agents, so they can find your product and sign up without a person stepping in
Conversion and Web Design
Conversion rate optimization of your pages, forms, and trial flows
SaaS website design that guides visitors to a demo request and is easy for AI agents to navigate
SaaS Paid Search
Google Ads management to protect brand terms and capture competitor searches
Consulting and Broader Marketing
GEO / AEO consulting for companies with strong in-house content teams
Wider marketing services, including fractional CMO, demand generation, and lead generation

How Our SEO & GEO Approaches Differ

Both agencies cover the same basics, like technical SEO, content, links, and PR, but they put their focus in different places. Here are two of the bigger differences.

1. Off-site work

At Singularity, our off-site work spreads one clear message about your product to the places buyers and AI already read. Alongside link building and digital PR, we distribute your content across LinkedIn, Reddit, Medium, and industry publications, so AI keeps finding the same picture of what you do. First Page Sage’s off-site work centers on reputation. They get you onto ranked lists and into databases, manage your reviews, publicize your awards, and monitor how people talk about you. Those levers work best for an established brand that already has a track record to build on.

2. What’s included beyond SEO and GEO

First Page Sage also offers website design and agentic search optimization, which gets your site ready for AI agents to find your product and sign up without a person stepping in. We keep our focus on SEO and GEO. We don’t design websites, but we review your pages and give your dev team recommendations to improve conversions. We also don’t offer agentic search optimization, by choice. At an early stage, pages that work well for buyers and are easy for AI to read cover most of what agents need.

For an early-stage SaaS founder watching AI recommend bigger competitors every time, this kind of focused work is what gets your product into those answers. To see what it would look like for your product, book a call and come pick our brains for free.

Account Management and Reporting

At Singularity

  • Our founder works on your strategy, and a dedicated team carries it out. Because we’re a small agency, Patrick Herbert is directly involved with every client, so the person you talk to before signing stays with you. You’ll also get an SEO account manager, writer, editor, and outreach specialist.
  • We communicate quickly and keep you updated every week. You can reach us directly over Slack and email. We also send weekly reports covering changes in your rankings, traffic, and AI visibility, what we did, and what’s next, and a shared dashboard lets you check progress anytime.
  • Monthly reports show the bigger picture. Each month, we put together a rundown of results and next month’s plans, in plain language.

At First Page Sage

  • A campaign manager coordinates your team. They’re your main contact, handling scheduling, meeting agendas, and action items, while an SEO strategist, writers, an editor, graphic artists, and web developers each own a part of the work.
  • Writers work directly with your team. They sit in on regular calls with your team to gather input for your content.
  • A reporting specialist builds your reports. A reporting specialist builds your reports, but they don’t specify the delivery or the frequency on their site.

The Takeaway

  • For early-stage companies: having Singularity’s founder directly involved in your strategy means decisions happen fast and nothing gets lost between layers of people. You can test, adjust, and move quickly, which is what a small team needs.
  • For established companies: a bigger program has more moving parts and more people on your side to keep in the loop. A campaign manager running the schedule, with a specialist owning each area, keeps all of that organized as the work scales.

Pricing Overview: Singularity Digital vs First Page Sage

Singularity Digital

  • SEO and GEO retainers from $3,000/month
  • SaaS PPC from $2,000/month
  • SEO consulting from $1,000/month

First Page Sage

Final Thoughts on Singularity Digital vs First Page Sage

Both agencies are good at what they do, so the right choice comes down to your fit and budget.

Singularity Digital Is a Good Fit for You If

  • You’re an early-stage SaaS company in the $1-10M ARR range with an agency budget of around $3K to $5K a month
  • You want to stand out to the buyers your product serves best, even with bigger competitors in your space
  • You want experts who’ve grown early-stage SaaS companies through search directly involved in your strategy
  • You want every hour and every dollar going into the SEO and GEO work that moves your visibility

If that sounds like your company, book a free consultation and tell us what you’re up against. If we’re not the right fit, we’ll say so.

First Page Sage Is a Good Fit for You If

  • You’re an established company that’s already known in your space, with a budget in the $6K to $12K+ range
  • You want to be the first name buyers and AI reach for in a crowded category
  • You want more under one roof, including agentic search optimization and website design

If you like parts of both approaches and that’s making the decision hard, get in touch. We’ll look at your product and your goals, help you work out what you actually need, and tell you if we’re the right team for the job.

Authors

Scroll to Top